The Poisonous Tomato That Built a 100-Year Business


Founder and Head of Growth, White Label Comedy
How do you build a business that lasts for generations?
By creating the conditions for success instead of waiting for them. The companies that last are rarely the ones who waited for proof, permission or best practices. They are the ones who saw an opportunity everyone else dismissed as too risky, and had the nerve to act on it before it was obviously safe.
When tomatoes were "poisonous"
Back in 1876, a lot of people genuinely believed tomatoes were poisonous.
So the business experts of the day were clear: there was no future in tomato-based products, especially not in mass consumer markets like sauces and condiments. On top of that, the market was already saturated with brown, vinegar-based sauces, because that is what people were used to.
Every sensible signal said: do not build a business on the tomato.
"Watch me"
Henry Heinz looked at all of that and thought, roughly, "watch me".
He did not wait for public opinion to shift. He did not wait for someone else to prove tomatoes were safe first. He ran his own studies, published the health benefits, and set up free tastings so people could try it and decide for themselves. And in doing so, he more or less single-handedly created the entire market for tomato-based condiments.
Now you cannot picture a burger without ketchup. Heinz is still dominating shelves 150 years later, while the "safe" vinegar sauce companies are long gone. He did not wait for perfect conditions. He created them.
Every industry has its own tomatoes
Here is why this still matters. Every industry has its own "poisonous tomatoes": the things people insist are not ready, or are too risky, or are best left until someone else has figured them out.
Take AI right now. Some businesses are cramming it into everything. Others are avoiding it like, well, a poisonous tomato. But most are simply sitting on the sidelines, waiting for case studies, waiting for best practices, waiting for permission, while quietly booking meetings about the potential planning of future strategy sessions.
The winners write the case studies
To be clear, this is not an argument for rushing into anything without thinking, and it is not about AI specifically. It is about a mindset.
The companies that last for generations are not the ones who waited for a playbook. They are the ones who wrote it. They test, they learn, they adapt, and they create the case studies everyone else is waiting to read. While their competitors prepare for meetings about meetings, they are out there being the proof.
The opportunity in your market is probably something people are still calling a poisonous tomato. The question is whether you will wait for permission, or go and grow it.
Meet Brian
Standing out means being willing to do what your more cautious competitors will not, and that includes marketing that actually gets noticed. That is where Brian, our AI Comedy Marketing Machine, comes in.
Brian helps you create bold, genuinely entertaining marketing while everyone else plays it safe and forgettable, using the same frameworks our own writers use.
Take Brian for a spin and start writing your own playbook instead of waiting for someone else's.

Adam Hunt
Founder and Head of Growth at White Label Comedy. He spends his days convincing serious brands that funny is the most profitable thing they're not doing.
Your marketing isn’t broken. It’s just boring.
It’s time you met the agency behind the internet’s most profitable funny brands.
Work with us

